federalism-and-state-relations
Amandla KaHulumeni: Kwenzekani Lapho Behluleka?
Table of Contents
Ukudlala phakathi kwemibuso kahulumeni nombuso kwakha i-parrock yokubusa kwaseMelika, nokho kuseyinye yezici eziphikiswana kakhulu nezinhlobo zezombangazwe zase-U.S. kubafundisi, abafundi, nezakhamuzi, iqonda ukuthi lokhu kunamandla kubalulekile ekuqondeni indlela enziwa ngayo imithetho, ephoqelelwe, futhi ephikiswa. Nakuba uMthetho-sisekelo unikeza ipulani, iqiniso liyinkimbinkimbi kakhulu, linezindawo ezihlukene ngokuvamile eziholela ezimpini ezingokomthetho, ukusungulwa kwezimiso, nokudidelwa komphakathi. Lesihloko sinweba ngezimiso eziyisisekelo, sihlola izindawo ezibucayi zokuhlangana, izihloko zeNkanto evelele, futhi siqokomisa imiphumela yemfundo nokuphila kwansuku zonke.
IZisekelo Zomthetho - sisekelo ZobuFenisi
UMthetho-sisekelo wase-U.S. awudali isigaba esiphansi esivamile; kunalokho, umisa isimiso sikahulumeni esihlukanisa ubukhosi phakathi kukahulumeni wesizwe nezwe. Lokhu kuhlukana kubalulekile ekulondolozeni ukuzibusa kukahulumeni kuyilapho belondoloza ukuhlangana okuhlangene. Abalawuli, bathonywa ongqondongqondo njengoMontesquieu futhi bedwetshwa ekuhlulekeni kweZigaba ze-Confederation, bafuna ukwakha isimiso esiyovimbela ukubusa ngombuso ngokususa amandla.
Amandla Aphathiwe, Agciniwe Namanje
Imibuso ephathiswe (noma ehlelwe) yileyo enikezwa ngokuqondile uhulumeni kahulumeni kahulumeni ngeSiphakamiso I, isiqephu 8 soMthetho-sisekelo. Lezi zihlanganisa amandla okulawula ezohwebo zezwe, ukumemezela impi, ukuphakamisa amabutho, ukumisa amaposi, nemali. Amagunya agciniwe, avikelwe yiSichibiyelo seshumi, yilawo angaphathiswanga uhulumeni kahulumeni noma anqatshelwe ezwe. Lezi zihlanganisa ukuqondisa ezohwebo zezentengiselwano, ukuqhuba ukhetho, ukumisa uhulumeni bendawo, nokuphatha impilo yomphakathi, ukuphepha, nemfundo. Imibuso ehlangene ehlangene ihlangene ihlangene nezingahlanganye nezingasigaba zombili zikahulumeni, njengamandla entela, ukuboleka imali, ukumisa izinkantolo, nokuphoqethiswa kwemithetho.
Umehluko phakathi kwemibuso ebaliwe nebekelwe isisekelo, kodwa ngokomthetho, ukuchazwa kwalezizigaba kuye kwakhula futhi kwathatha indawo ngokuhamba kwesikhathi. I-difaict and Theist Claus (Ingxenye I, Ingxenye 8, u-Claus 18) inikeza uMkhandlu igunya lokwenza yonke imithetho "edingekile nefanele" yokufeza amandla ayo, aye asetshenziselwa ukwandisa igunya likahulumeni ngokuphawulekayo.
UClaus Onedumela Elibi Nokukhululwa
Uma imithetho kahulumeni ne-hulumeni iphikisana, i-Supremacy Claus (Artle VI, Clausle 2) imisa ukuthi uMthetho-sisekelo, imithetho kahulumeni, nezivumelwano kuyi-"uMthetho weZwe"owe-omthetho kahulumeni" lokhu kusho ukuthi abahluleli kuzo zonke izifunda baboshwe umthetho kahulumeni, futhi imithetho-mthetho kahulumeni ephikisana nomthetho kahulumeni ayisebenzi. Nokho, ukusebenzisa i-Supremacy Claus awumcan akacacile ngaso sonke isikhathi. Izinkantolo kumelwe zinqume ukuthi umthetho wombuso uphikisana nomthetho kahulumeni ngempela noma uwele ngaphakathi kwendawo ehloselwe ukushiya uvulekile kumthetho wezwe.
Izinhlobo Zokuhlengwa
Ukukhululwa kungavela ngezindlela eziningana:
- Ukuhlengwa: Uma umthetho kahulumeni usho ngokucacile ukuthi udlula umthetho wezwe endaweni ethile. Ngokwesibonelo, i-Airline Deregial Act ihlanganisa ilungiselelo elicacile lokukhulula.
- Icushwe ngendumiso: Uma umthetho kahulumeni ubanzi kangangokuba awushiyi thuba lomthetho wezwe ("indawo yokuhlengwa"), noma uma umthetho wombuso uphikisana ngokuqondile nomthetho kahulumeni ("ukuhlengwa").
INkantolo Ephakeme iye yasungula indikimba eqinile ewuphawu oluhle ngokuhlengwa, ngokuvamile ihlaziya injongo yoMkhandlu ngokumelene nemibuso yamaphoyisa avamile yalemibuso.
Izindawo Eziyinhloko Zokweqisa Nokuxabana
Imithetho eshaya ihlombe kakhulu ibonakala ngokucacile ezinkundleni lapho ohulumeni bombuso nohulumeni bethi banegunya khona.
Ukuqashelwa Ngokomthetho
Mhlawumbe indawo ephikiswana kakhulu yempi ekhona ihilela insangu. I-Guedid Substances Act kahulumeni ihlukanisa insangu njengesidakamizwa se-Shedylma, ikhiqiza, isakaza, futhi ibe nezindawo ezingekho emthethweni ngaphansi komthetho kahulumeni. Nokho, kusukela ngo- 1996, inani elandayo lezifunda liye lagunyaza insangu emishayiselwayo ukuze ithole izinjongo zokwelapha noma zokuzilibazisa. Lokhu kudala izingxabano eziqondile: abantu ngabanye namabhizinisi asebenza ngaphansi komthetho kahulumeni ahlala esengozini yokuquliswa. Nokho, nge-Rocracerbach·Blamore andementment futhi kamuva i-Cole Meyandrandment (untlylycevreav), i-ousced , i-Gwacelcerl, i-om, i-omscercet, i-om, izigorist (injini ezisemthethweni ze-Colustra, i-Gripticstings, i-R. kodwa i-angs.
Ukunakekela Impilo Kushintsha Nesenzo Sokunakekela Esingadunyi
I-Patient Protection and Affordal Care Act (ACA) ka-2010 iveza amagunya adlulele ekunakekeleni impilo. Uhulumeni wakhona wamisa isisekelo sezimfuneko zokukhokhela, wagunyaza umshuwalense (kamuva waphinde wakhishwa) futhi wanwetshwa uMdicaid. Nokho, isinqumo seNkantolo Ephakeme iNational Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius[[FLT:] [20] [20] (202] uhulumeni wezwe ngalinye uphethe ukuthi awukwazi ukuphoqeqelela ukunyusa uMdic ngokusongela ukukhipha yonke iminyango ekhona. Lokhu kwaphumela ekukhetheni kwezwe ngezwezwezwezwezwezwezwezwezwe: njengo 2024, cishe ama-40 aye anwebenyuswa ngaphansi kwe-ACCA, kuyilapho le ndawo ingasebenzi.
Ukuthunyelwa Kwamandla Okufuduka
Isimiso sokuhlanganisa siwumthwalo wemfanelo kahulumeni oqinile, kodwa imibuso iye yazama ukumisa igunya ngemithetho enjenge-Arizona’s S.B. 1070 (2070), eyafuna ukuqiniswa komthetho kahulumeni ukuze kuhlolwe ukufuduka phakathi namakhawulo. Arizora v. United States [202], iNkantolo Ephakeme yabulala umthetho njengededelwa umthetho kazwelo, kodwa yasekela "ngibonise ilungiselelo lakho", izihloko eziqhubekayo ezingokomthetho. Ngokuphikisanayo, "idolobha elinamathelelayo" imingcele yendawo yokubambisana neziphathimandla zezezokufuduka. Le nkundla yempi iveza ukungavumelani okujulileyo ezindaweni eziswayo noma ezisekunqabeni zokuthutha. I-Australia isekela izimo eziphambili zikahulumeni isebenzisa futhi ikhiphe imibandela engokomthetho ezindaweni zokuxosha.
Ukubuyiselwa Kwendawo Ezungezile
Umthetho wendawo ezungezile ungomunye umkhakha ogcwele ukucindezeleka kwezwe kukahulumeni. I-Cealor Air Act ne-Ceaner Water Act imisa izindinganiso zikahulumeni, kodwa izifundazwe zivame ukuba nomthwalo wokusebenzisa futhi zikwazi ukusebenzisa imithetho eqinile. Ngokwesibonelo, iCalifornia, ithole i-Chrean Air Active Active ukuze ibeke izindinganiso zayo siqu zemoto. Ngokufana, izifunda zikahulumeni ezimbalwa ziye zathatha izinga lokulawula i-Trump zavala i-computer'irnoval'umler e-compactives. Nokho, ukulawula i-Trump kwabangela ukuba i-compactivern ekhul'untry'umgatedy'irn, okuholela ekumangazweni kweNkantolo Ephezulu, futhi kuthathelwe esikhundleni se-Trump kuqhubeke ukuqondisa okungokomthetho okungokomthetho wokulawula i-Slove.
Ukulawula Izibhamu
ISichibiyelo Sesibili simelela ilungelo lokuphatha izikhali, kodwa bobabili ohulumeni bamazwe nohulumeni balawula ukuba nezibhamu. Umthetho kahulumeni kaGun Control ka-1968 kanye noMthetho we-Brady Handgun Violence Prevention Act umise imithetho evimbela isisekelo. Nokho, amazwe aye amisa imithetho ehlukene kakhulu, kusukela emvumeleni ethwele ezinye izizwe kuya ekuhloleni isizinda somhlaba wonke nasekuvimbeleni kwezikhali eziqinile. Isinqumo seNkantolo Ephakeme ku [FLD: 0] iNew York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen[FLT:] [2022] yashaya phansi umbuso wezwe lonke ofihle izikhali, iphethe ukuthi imvume yeSiphetho sifuna ukuba kuvumelane ukudutshulwa kwemithetho engokomlando. Lokhu kubangele ukuba kubeke inselele eminye imithetho yemithetho yezempi, impikiswano yemithetho yesifunda sezwe futhi iphinde ikhiphe isibhamu.
Indima YeNkantolo Ephakeme Ekuxazululeni Impi Yesifundazwe
INkantolo Ephakeme ingumsizi wokugcina wezingxabano zombuso kahulumeni. izinqumo zezimpawu ziye zathonya imingcele yamandla kahulumeni wezwe nemibuso.
McCulloch v. Maryland (1819)
Lelicala lesisekelo lasungula ukuthi uhulumeni kahulumeni unamandla aqonde ngaphezu kwalawo ahlelwe ngokuqondile, futhi lowo mbuso awunakukhokha intela yezinhlangano zikahulumeni. UMahluleli omkhulu uJohn Marshall wabhala ukuthi "amandla entela ahlanganisa amandla okubhubhisa," nokuthi uMthetho-sisekelo usuka kubantu, hhayi emibuso. Lokhu kwaqinisa igunya elibanzi likahulumeni nesimiso sokuthi umthetho kahulumeni awukwazi ukuvimbela ukusebenza okungokomthetho okungokomthetho.
Gibbons v. Ogden (1824)
Lelicala lacacisa izinga lezentengiselwano zika Claus, liphethe ukuthi amandla oMkhandlu wokulawula ezentengiselwano zamazwe aphakathi, kungenxa yezindlela cishe zonke zezentengiselwano ezinqamule imikhakha kahulumeni. Lesi sinqumo sanika uhulumeni uhulumeni amandla okulawula imikhumbi, futhi kamuva, izindawo ezinjengezindawo zamalungelo omphakathi, izindinganiso zezisebenzi, kanye nesivikelo sendawo ezungezile.
United States v. Lopez (1995)
Emngceleni ongavamile wamandla ezentengiselwano, iNkantolo yabulala uMthetho weGun-Free School Schools njengegunya elidlula igunya loMkhandlu. INkantolo yacabanga ukuthi ukuba nesibhamu eduze kwesikole akuyithinti kakhulu ibhizinisi lezifunda zomhlaba, ukuphawula ukubuya kobuhulumeni obuhlangene. Amacala alandelanayo anjenge United States v. Morrison [2] [2] ne-NFIB v. Sebelius[FLT][FLY] [[FLT]] (202]]) aqhubeka nokuchaza imingcele yamandla kahulumeni.
National Collegiate Athletic Association (2088)
Lelicala labulala iProfessional and Amateraur Sports Providection Act (PASPA), eyayinqabele ukugunyaza ukubheja ezemidlalo. Inkantolo yathi i-PASPA yaphula imfundiso emelene nokuyalela. Isimiso sokuthi uMkhandlu awunakuphoqelela ngokuqondile ukuba umise noma usebenzise izimiso zokuqondisa. Lesi sinqumo siye senza ukuba amazwe agunyaze ukubheja ezemidlalo, futhi manje kunamazwe angaphezu kwangu-30 enza kanjalo.
Izingcindezi Zomthetho Wemfundo
Ukuhlangana kwemibuso kahulumeni nekazwe kungokubaluleke kakhulu emfundweni, insimu evame ukuthonywa yizwe kodwa ethonywa isimiso sikahulumeni. UMthetho - sisekelo awuyikhulumi ngemfundo, kodwa uhulumeni ufeza indima ebalulekile ngokuxhasa imali, ngokuphoqelela ukugcinwa kwamalungelo abantu, nangokuziphendulela ezindinganisweni.
Wonke Umfundi Uphumelelayo Enzweni (Essa)
Eqanjwe ngo-2015, i-ESSA yathatha indawo ye-No Child Lend Behind Act futhi yabuyisela uhulumeni othile esikhundleni se-odoli ngesikhathi igcina izimfuneko zonyaka nokubika. Kodwa manje amazwe anikezwa ithuba lokuzivumelanisa nokuhlela izimiso zawo zokuziphendulela, amise iziqondiso zemfundo, futhi anqume ukungenela ezikoleni eziphansi. Lolu shintsho lubonisa ukuqhubekela ekubuseni kwe-buthoristrianism, lapho uhulumeni ubeka khona imigomo ebanzi kodwa unquma ukuthi uzoyifinyelela kanjani. Nokho, uMnyango Wemfundo usazibukeza izicwangciso zikahulumeni futhi ungagodla imali uma uhluleka ukuhlangabezana nezimfuneko.
Isihloko I Nezimali Zokusekela Imali
Isihloko I somthetho we-Elementary and Secondary Education Act sinikeza izimali ezikoleni zikahulumeni ezinamaphesenti aphezulu abafundi abavela emikhayeni ehlwishiwe. Ukwamukela isiHloko semali engiyikhokhayo ezikoleni nasemikhawulweni kahulumeni, kuhlanganise nalezo ezihlobene nezimfanelo zothisha, intuthuko yesikole, nokuhileleka kwabazali. Lokhu kwenza i-carrot-ant-past: izishaya-mali futhi ngaleyondlela zivumelane nemithetho ethile. Umphumela uyisimiso esixubile lapho ukulawula kwezwe kulawulwa izinto eziza kuqala zikahulumeni.
Izimpikiswano Ezivamile Nezindinganiso
Izifundo zeMigangatho yeSizwe iCorame Core State, ezasungulwa ababusi bezwe nabaphathi bemfundo, zamukelwa ngokuzithandela yizifundazwe eziningi. Nokho, izisusa zikahulumeni (njenge-Fource to the Treacess neslars ezisuka kuNo Child Ole Beyind) zakhuthaza ukutholwa, zaholela abagxeki ukuba babheke iCommon Core njengenobuqili bamazwe kazwelonke. Kamuva amazwe amaningana ahlehla noma abukele izindinganiso, aqokomisa ukukhathalela kwezombangazwe ithonya likahulumeni emfundweni. Izwe lamanje liveza ingxube yezindinganiso zikahulumeni ezithuthukisiwe futhi likhuthaza i-pale-paleji.
Amalungelo Omphakathi Nemfundo Ekhethekile
Imithetho ye-Federal enjengethi Antes of Diculture Education Act (IDEA), i-Title IX, ne-Civil Rights Act inqabela ubandlululo futhi ifuna ukuba kunikezwe izivumelwano ezilinganayo zemfundo. I-IDEA inikeza iziqondiso ezifanele zomphakathi (FAPE) kubafundi abakhubazekile, ngokuxhasa izindleko zikahulumeni. Izwe lisebenzisa lezinhlelo futhi lingazinikeza iziqondiso zikahulumeni, kodwa ukuphoqesha uhulumeni ukuba ugcine uhulumeni uhileleke kakhulu.
Isiphetho: Ukucindezeleka Okuhlala Njalo KobuFalistism
Amagunya ahlalisanayo ohulumeni bakahulumeni bakahulumeni nohulumeni awasona isici kodwa isici sesimiso saseMelika esivumela ukuvumelana nezimo, ukuhlola, nenkulumo-mphikiswano. Nokho, lesi sakhiwo sibuye sibangele izingxabano, ukungaguquguquki, nokudideka. Ukusukela ekutholeni insangu kuya ekwandisweni kweMdicaid, kusukela ekuqikelelweni kwezokufuduka kuya ezindinganisweni zemfundo, ukulinganisela kwezwe kuhlala kuyimpikiswano ephilayo ebangela ukuguquguquka kwezombangazwe nokuqondana nokwahlulela. Ukuqonda lokhu kubaluleke kakhulu kubafundisi abalungiselela abafundi isisekelo somthetho womphakathi, izimpikiswano zeze, izimpikiswano zezehlule, nezimiso zangempela zomhlaba, abafundi, futhi izakhamuzi zingahamba ngekhono lokubusa ngokuqonda okukhulu.
Ukuze bahlole ngokwengeziwe lezindaba, abafundi bangahlola umbhalo ogcwele woMthetho-sisekelo eNational Archives, noma babukeze izinqumo zeNkantolo ePhakeme ngo-Oyez. I-Congregal Research Service ikhipha imibiko ephathelene nohulumeni onikeza ukuhlaziywa kobuzwe okungekhona kwesigaba. Ukusebenzisa lemithombo kusiza ekuqondeni ngokujulile ukuthi imibuso ehlangene neyombuso isebenzelana kanjani nokuthi kungani ibalulekile.