Table of Contents

Isingeniso: Ubuhlobo Obuthinta Izakhamuzi Nohulumeni

Ezimisweni zentando yeningi, ubuhlobo phakathi kwezakhamuzi nohulumeni wazo abukho obungaguquguquki. Kudinga ukunakekelwa njalo, ukunikezwa imvume, nokulandisa. Enhlonhlweni yale nkinga eshukumisayo kuqashelwa isakhamuzi − ukuhlanganyela okukhuthele kwabantu ezimisweni zezombangazwe nezokuphatha ezilawulayo ezilawula ukuphila kwabo. Uma kuklanyelwe ngokuphumelelayo, ukubophana kunikeza abantu izwi elingaphezu kokunikeza abantu iphimbo; kusebenza njengokuhlolwa okunamandla ngamandla, ukuphoqelela izenzo zikahulumeni ekukhanyeni nasekuzihlanganiseni nezindinganiso ezifanele. Lokhu kuhlola okukhudlwana okungokwenani lezakhamuzi kuhlola indlela yokuveza ngayo ukukhanya okusobala kohulumeni nezimiso zokuziphatha, ukuchaza inqubo yokuhlanganyela okuveza ngayo ukulandisa okukhulu, ukuvula, nokubusa ngezimiso ezingokomthetho wangempela, ukubhekana nezinselele ezingapheli, nokuhlelwa kohlelo oluqhubekayo kohulumeni nemiphakathi ebanzi.

Ukuqonda Isabelo Sezakhamuzi: Ngaphandle Kokuzincoma

Ukuthembisana kwezakhamuzi kuhlanganisa imisebenzi eminingi ngaphandle kokufaka ifomu lemali njalo eminyakeni embalwa. Limelela ingxoxo eqhubekayo phakathi kwezinhlangano zomphakathi nabantu ezibakhonzayo. Ukuthembisana okunenjongo kuvumela izakhamuzi ukuba zithonye uhlelo lwenqubo, uhlelo lwemali, ukuthunyelwa kwenkonzo, kanye nokwengamela. Izindlela eziyinhloko zokuthembisana zihlanganisa:

  • Ukuhlola nokukhipha imvume: amahholo edolobha, amajaji ezakhamuzi, kanye namaqembu abhekisa phambili aqoqa ukwaziswa ngezimiso ezihlongozwayo.
  • Ukuhlola nokuhlolwa kwenombolo: iqoqo lombono womphakathi ukuze kwaziswe ukwenza isinqumo.
  • Ukuhlela nokuqamba ama-advocation: I- Grassroots kanye nezinhlangano ezingezona ezohulumeni ezisekela izimbangela ezithile.
  • [[I-FLT:0] Izindawo zomthonga nezindawo zobulungu: amathuluzi enza ukuba kube nokunikeza ukwaziswa kwangempela kanye nokusakaza imiqondo.
  • Ukuhlelwa kwesimiso sokuhlela nokuhlela: okuqondile kulawula izingxenye zezinqumo zokusetshenziswa komphakathi noma zokusetshenziswa kwezwe.

Ngayinye yalemizila ifeza injongo ehlukene: inikeza izakhamuzi amandla okulungisa imiphumela futhi ngesikhathi esifanayo ibangela ukucindezela kokuba ohulumeni basebenze ngendlela esobala nengokokuziphatha. Izinga okuthi ukuthembisana kuphumelele lixhomeke ekuklanyweni kwezimiso, kwezombangazwe, nasekutholakaleni kwamathuba okuhlanganyela. Uma isithembiso singekho ngqile noma singalawulwa kahle, singaqeda ukwethembana kunokuba sikwakhe.

Ukuhlobana Okuqondile Phakathi Kokuhlanganyela Nokubona Izindawo Ngohulumeni

Isimiso sokubona ngaphaya kwezwe (-) isimiso sokuthi izenzo zikahulumeni, izinqumo, kanye nokwaziswa kufanele kuvuleke ukuze kuhlolwe umphakathi, okuyitshe eliyinhloko lokubusa okuhle. Isivumelwano sezakhamuzi siqinisa ukubonakala ngokuqondile ngezindlela ezine ezihlangene:

Ukufinyelela kolwazi okufunwayo

Izakhamuzi ezihlangene ngokwemvelo zinelukuluku lokwazi ukuthi izinqumo zenziwa kanjani nokuthi zisetshenziswa kanjani. Njengoba zihlanganyela ekuhloleni, ekuhlanganyeleni emihlanganweni yomkhandlu, noma ekuthumeleni izicelo zenkululeko zokwaziswa okufinyelelwe, zakha isidingo esiqhubekayo sokwaziswa okufinyelelwe. Lokhu kuphoqelela izinhlangano zikahulumeni ukuba zikhiphe izilinganiso zemali, imizuzu yomhlangano, ukulanda amarekhodi, nokusebenza. Ngokuhamba kwesikhathi, ukuthembisa okuvamile kwenza ukuthulula izigwegwegwe, kwenza kube yindawo ehlukile kunokuba kube umthetho.

Ukuhlolwa Nokugadiswa

Uma izakhamuzi zihileleke ngenkuthalo ekuhloleni imisebenzi kahulumeni − ngokuhlola amaqembu aqapheyo, ukuhlola umphakathi, noma ukuhlola imisebenzi yomphakathi ngokwengxenye kusebenza njengendlela yokuqondisa ngokwethukela. Lokhu kunciphisa amathuba okuziphatha okungabonakali. Ngokwesibonelo, ukugadelwa kwemisebenzi yezezisekelo ezisemkhakheni emazweni asathuthuka kuye kwaboniswa ukuthi kunciphisa izindleko ezisetshenziswa kakhulu nokuthuthukisa izinga lemisebenzi, njengoba kufakazelwa yi- World Bank yokulandisa komphakathi [.

Izindawo Zokufaka Izithelo Ezivala Igebe Lokwaziswa

Ukubona gcakasha akukona nje ukukhipha imininingwane; kungokokuqinisekisa ukuthi ukwaziswa kuyaqondwa futhi kusetshenziswa. Ukuthembisa kwezakhamuzi kuveza izici ezivumelanayo lapho ohulumeni bengahlola khona ukuthi ukudalula kwabo kufinyelela izilaleli ezihlongozwayo nokuthi umphakathi ungaqondana yini. Ngokwesibonelo, uma idolobha likhipha uhlelo lwalo lokusetshenziswa kwalo kuyi-intanethi, izakhamuzi ezibophekile zingabuza imibuzo ecacisa imibuzo ngezikhathi zangempela, zishukumisela izikhulu ukuba zinikeze izifushaniso ezicacile zolimi. Lokhu kugeleza okubili kujulisa ukukhanya ngaphandle kokwenza izincwadi nje.

Ukwethemba Njengembewu Yokukhululeka

Impikiswane ephindaphindwayo, enenjongo yakha ukwethembana. Uma izakhamuzi zibona ukuthi ukufakwa kwazo kuholela ezinguqulweni ezibonakalayo noma ukuthi imibuzo yazo ithola izimpendulo eziqotho, zisengozini kakhulu yokukholelwa ebuqothweni bezinqubo zikahulumeni. Ukuthembana, kukhuthaza ukuthembisana okwengeziwe, ukwenza umjikelezo omuhle oqinisa ukubonakala. [i-OLT] [i-OLD] njalo] ithole ukuthi ukukhulumisana okukhanyayo kanye nokuhlanganyela kwezakhamuzi kuyizihlupho eziyinhloko zokuthembela komphakathi kuhulumeni.

Indlela Ukuhlanganyela Okuphakamisa Ngayo Izindinganiso Ezingokwesiko Ekubuseni

Izimiso zokuziphatha kuhulumeni zibhekisela ezimisweni zokuziphatha eziqondisa ukuziphatha okusemthethweni (ukuthembeka, ubuqotho, ukungakhethi, nokugwema izingxabano zesithakazelo. Ukuthembisana kwezakhamuzi kuqinisa izimiso zokuziphatha ngezindlela eziningi:

Ukulandisa Okwandayo Ngokuziphatha Okungekuhle

Uma izakhamuzi ziqaphile futhi zinezindlela zokubika ukuziphatha okubi, ingozi yokuphambuka kwezimiso zokuziphatha iba nkulu kakhulu ezikhulwini zomphakathi. Ama Hotlines, amabhodi abaphathi bezakhamuzi, kanye nokuthethwa kwecala komphakathi kuvumela abantu ukuba bamemezele ukuphambana, ukufumbathisa, noma ukusetshenziswa kabi kwezimali zomphakathi. Ukuba khona kwezakhamuzi eziboshweyo kuvimbela ukuphula umthetho ngenxa yokuthi amathuba okudalulwa ayanda. Ngokwesibonelo, iQelelo laseNdiya lokwaziswa, lihlangene namaqembu ezisebenzi ezikhuthele, kuye kwaba yithuluzi ekudaleni ukonakala ezimisweni zomphakathi.

Indalo Ephelele Yesimiso Semfundo

Ufakelwa kwezakhamuzi kungahlela izimiso ezibonisa izindinganiso ezizivumelanisayo. Izinqubo ezizinzileyo zivumela imiphakathi ukuba ixoxe ngezokuthengwa kwezindawo ezizungezile njengokungathi ilinganise ukuthuthuka kwezomnotho ngokuvikela indawo ezungezile((*) futhi ifinyelele ezinqumweni izakhamuzi ezizibheka njengezilungile. Le ndlela yokuzibandakanya inciphisa izingozi zokuthi izimiso ziyokwenza izithakazelo eziphambili ezingcono kakhulu ngokuncishiswa umphakathi.

Ukunciphisa Ukonakala Ngokulandisa Komphakathi

Ukulandisa kwezenhlalo (laha izakhamuzi ziqondisa izinkonzo zomphakathi ngokuqondile futhi zigcina abaxhasi bazo zinokulandisa − kuye kwabonakala kuphumelela ekunqandeni inkohlakalo. Izinyathelo ezifana namakhadi aneziphakamiso zomphakathi namakhadi omphakathi abika anikeza abasebenzisi indlela ehleliwe yokulinganisela izinga lenkonzo nenani elingekho ngokwemithetho yefulege. I-meta-analysis ye- ye-United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs [] yathola ukuthi amathuluzi anjalo, uma esekelwa ukusabela kukahulumeni, anciphisa kakhulu ukuvuza ezimisweni zomphakathi.

Ukwakha Isiko Lobuqotho

Ngaphandle kwezenzakalo zomuntu ngamunye, ukuthembisana ngokuqhubekayo kuthuthukisa isiko lapho ukuziphatha okuhle kuyinto evamile. Uma izakhamuzi zihlanganyela njalo ekubuseni, zilindela ($ne) futhi zifuna ukuba abaholi bazo babe nezindinganiso eziphakeme.

Ukuhlola Icala Okubonisa Ukuguquka

Izibonelo zezwe langempela zibonisa indlela isithembiso sezakhamuzi esiye sathuthukisa ngayo ngokuphawulekayo ukubonakala nokuhluzeka kwezindinganiso phakathi kwezindawo ezihlukene zokubusa.

Ukuhlanganyela Ekuhlelweni Kwemali EPorto Alegre, eBrazil

Kusukela ekusungulweni kwayo ngo- 1989, inqubo yokuhlela imali yokuhlukanisa iye yavumela izakhamuzi ukuba zinqume ngokuqondile ukuthi zingayihlela kanjani ingxenye yemali kamasipala. Izakhamuzi ziya emihlanganweni yomphakathi ukuze zihlolele futhi zivote ngokusebenzisa izinto eziza kuqala(ukusuka ekukhuculeni kuya emfundweni.) Umphumela uye waba ukwanda okukhulu kokubonakala obala: izincwadi zokuhlela uhlelo lwemali zidingidwa obala, futhi izindleko zihlolwa kakhulu abameleli bomphakathi. Ucwaningo lubonisa ukuthi lenqubo incishisiwe i-relisealism futhi iphinde isetshenziswe ezikhwameni ezibekwe ngokwezikhundla, ithuthukisa kokubili ukuhleleka nokwethemba kuhulumeni kamasipala. Ngokuzimele ukuqinisekiswa kokwaziswa okungatholi nzuzo kuqinisekisa ukuthi amakhothalithi emali ezindaweni zomphakathi eziseBrazil aphansi.

Ubudlelwane Obuvulekile Bukahulumeni (OGP)

I-OGP yaqala ngo-2011, iyisenzo sembulunga yonke esihlanganisa ohulumeni nomphakathi ukuba bahlanganisane ukuze basungule amasu esizwe ahloselwe ukwandisa ukubonakala bhabha, ukulandisa, nokuhlanganyela kwezakhamuzi. Amazwe angaphezu kuka-70 aye ahlanganyela, ezama ukulungisa izinto ezinjengokufinyela obala, ukuvezana komphakathi, kanye nokuqondisa kwezakhamuzi zezimboni ezikhiqizwayo. Ukuhlola komphakathi kubonisa ukuthi amazwe angamalungu e-OGP aye enza intuthuko ephawulekayo ekuboneleni kukhanya uma kuqhathaniswa nezinhlangano ezingezona. Isibonelo salo sivumelwano sibonisa indlela isibopho sezakhamuzi esibekwe kahle esizingeni lesizwe esingaqondisa ngayo izimiso zezimiso zokuziphatha.

Ukuphatha Umphakathi E - United States

Izinhlelo zomthetho zomphakathi .alapho izinhlangano eziphoqelela ukugcinwa komthetho zisebenza ngokuzikhandla nezakhamuzi ukuze zibone futhi zixazulule ezinye izinkinga zendawo . Ngokuveza ezinye izenzakalo ezinamandla zengxoxo, ukugibela izinhlelo ze-alm, kanye nezakhamuzi eziphethe, amakomiti amaphoyisa athuthukisa ukubonakala ngaphandle kwezimiso zomthetho nezenzo zokubuthwa kwabantu. Emadolobheni anjenge-Camden, New Jersey, ukubophana komphakathi kwaholela ekuncipheni kwezikhalo zezenzo zokukhononda nokusebenzisa izenzakalo ze-odollar, kuyilapho kufaka ithonya elikhulu lezentelekele yomphakathi. Imiphumela engokomthetho isobala: izikhulu zinomthwalo wemfanelo emiphakathini ezikhonza kuyo, futhi izakhamuzi zizizwa zinegunya lokubika ngaphandle kokwesaba ukuphindisela.

Izinselele Eziqhubekayo Ekubalweni Nezakhamuzi Eziphumelelayo

Naphezu kwezinzuzo zayo, ukwakha izakhamuzi eziqinile kubhekene nezithiyo ezibalulekile okumelwe ziqashelwe futhi zixazululwe.

Ulwazi Nokwehlukana Kwamanani

Ukubopha kudinga abaxhasi abanolwazi. Nokho ohulumeni abaningi abakwazi ukunikeza imininingwane kumafomethi angenakho ochwepheshe. Ulimi oluyinkimbinkimbi olungokomthetho, amawebhusayithi asakazekile, nokuntuleka kwezinkonzo zokuhumusha kungena ezindaweni eziphansi. Ngaphezu kwalokho, ukwehlukana kwezibalo kuyalingana---inthanethi ne-apply jal.

Ukunganaki Nokungathembani Kwezombangazwe

Kuyidemokrasi eminingi, umvoti uyaqhubeka encipha, futhi ukuthembela ezinhlanganweni kuphansi ngokomlando. Izakhamuzi ezinomuzwa wokuthi ukuhlanganyela kwazo ngeke kuholele ekushintsheni akunakwenzeka ukuba zingene. Lokhu kunganaki ngokuvamile kusuka ezithembisweni ezidlule ezephulwayo, ukubuza okungenangqondo, noma ukungasabeli kukahulumeni. Ukunqoba lokhu kudinga isibonakaliso esiqinile sokuthi ukuthembisana kuthinta imiphumela ngempela.

Imithombo Nemisebenzi Eyinkimbinkimbi

Isithembiso esinenzuzo sisekela imithombo yemali. Kudinga izimboni eziqeqeshiwe, amaplatifomu asebenza nge-tec, izinkonzo zokuhumusha, nesikhathi sezisebenzi ukuhlaziya ukwaziswa nombiko emuva. Ohulumeni abaningi bendawo, ikakhulukazi ezindaweni ezifika kancane, abanamali noma ulwazi lobuchwepheshe lokusekela izinqubo zokuhlela eziphezulu. Ngaphandle kwemithombo eyanele, ukuthembisana kuba yisishoshoshozelo, kunciphisa ikhono lako lokuthuthukisa ukubonakala nokuziphatha.

Ukumelana Nemibuso YasebuBureaucracy Nama - El ezombangazwe

Ukuzifaka inselele zokubekwa kwezakhiwo zokubusa. Abameli be-Bureaucrates nabezombangazwe abajwayele ukwenza izinqumo eziphezulu bangase bamelane nokuhlanganyela igunya nezakhamuzi. Kwezinye izimo, ukuthembisana kuncishiswa ngamabomu noma kubekwa indiva ukuze kuvikelwe izithakazelo ezingcono. Ukunqoba lokhu kudinga imiyalelo yomthetho, ukuqondisa okuzimele, kanye nokuqinisa umphakathi ukuze kuqinisekiswe ukuthi ukuthembisana akusona nje isenzo esiwuphawu.

Izinqubo Zokuhlanganyela Ekwakheni Izakhamuzi Ezijulile Nezongamele

Ukuze baqaphele izinzuzo ezisobala nezingokokuziphatha zokuthembisana, ohulumeni nomphakathi kumelwe basebenzise amasu aqondile, anezisusa ezinhle.

Izele Imfundo Nokuqaphela Imisebenzi

Izakhamuzi azinakuhlanganyela ngokuphumelelayo uma zingawaqondi amalungelo azo, ukusebenza kukahulumeni, noma izindaba ezithile ezihilelekile. Imikhankaso yemfundo yomphakathi ezikoleni, ezikhungweni zomphakathi, nakuyimithombo yezindaba ingakha ulwazi oluyisisekelo oludingekayo ukuze zithathe ulwazi olunolwazi. Ukubambisana namayunivesithi nezinzuzo ezingakhi ukunikeza iziyalezo ezilula zezinqubo zemali noma izinqubo zomthetho kuyisinyathelo esiwusizo.

Ubuchwepheshe Be - leverge obulwa Nokuncibilika Kwezinga

Ama-croplat anganciphisa izithiyo zokuhlanganyela, ikakhulukazi uma eklanyelwe ukufinyelela kumahamba-hamba, izilimi eziningi, futhi engekho ngaphandle kolayini. Izibonelo zihlanganisa izingosi zomphakathi eziqoqa iziteshi zezicelo ze-intanethi, namathuluzi angempela okunikeza izimvume zokuhambisa inkonzo. Nokho, ezobuchwepheshe kumele zibe yisithasiselo, hhayi ukubuyisela, ikakhulukazi ukuthembisana ubuso nobuso, ikakhulukazi emiphakathini enolwazi oluphansi. Ohulumeni futhi kufanele baqinisekise ukuthi amathuluzi obuchwepheshe avule imithombo futhi asebenza ukuze ugweme umthengisi okhiye futhi athole ulwazi olunendawo enele.

Yenza Izinhlangano Zivikele Izindawo Zokuhlanganyela

Ukuhlanganyela kuphumelela kakhulu lapho kuhlelwa njengenhlangano noma umthetho kunokuba kushiyelwe enqubeni yabaholi ngabanye. Izimfuneko ezisemthethweni zokuqulwa kwecala lomphakathi, ukuqulwa kwezakhamuzi, nezikhathi ezibophekile zemibuzo kudala amathemba aqinile. Amahhovisi azimele, njenge-ombustlecsman noma amahhovisi ezimiso zokusebenza noma ama-ombudsman anezimiso zokukhononda kwezakhamuzi, anika imvume yokubuyisela uma isithembiso sihluleka.

Ukuvama Kwamaqembu Ahlelwe Imingcele

Izinqubo zokuhlanganyela kumelwe zifinyelele ngokuzikhandla kwabesifazane, intsha, imiphakathi yabomdabu, abantu abakhubazekile, namanye amaqembu aphansi. Lokhu kungadinga ukuhlolwa, ukusetshenziswa kwezindawo ezifinyelelekayo namafomethi, amalungiselelo okunakekela izingane, nokusiza ekukhokheleni izindleko zokuhlanganyela. Uma lamaqembu ehlanganiswa, ukuhlukahluka kwemibono kunika inzuzo yokucabanga ngezimiso zokuhle nokuvimbela ukuthathwa kwezithakazelo eziphambili.

Vala I - defice

Enye yezikhalo ezivame kakhulu zezakhamuzi ukuthi ukufakwa kwazo kungena “ebhokisini elimnyama.” Ohulumeni kumelwe bazibophezele ukubika ukuthi izinqumo eziphenjelelwe ukuthembisana zithonywe kanjani, futhi kuhlanganisa nalapho umfakela ungamukelwanga, futhi kungani. Ukuvala indiva yempendulo kubonisa inhlonipho ngesikhathi nemibono yezakhamuzi, futhi kwakha ukwethenjelwa okudingekayo ukuze zihlanganyele ngokuqhubekayo.

Ikusasa Lokuhlanganyela Kwezakhamuzi: Ubuchwepheshe, Ukwaziswa, Nokubusa Okuyinkimbinkimbi

Njengoba amathuluzi asebenza ngemishini nemininingwane ye - anyalytic ziqhubeka ziguquka, amathuba amasha atholakalayo okuthembisana kwesakhamuzi ngokujule ngokwengeziwe.

Ukuhlakanipha Okuklanywe Ngezindlela Ezithile Nokuhlaziya

Ukuhlelwa kolimi olungokwemvelo kungahlaziya izinkulungwane zezinkulumo zomphakathi ngezimiso ezihlongozwayo, ukuhlukanisa izihloko eziyinhloko nemibono engasekelwe kakhulu. Lokhu kungasiza ohulumeni ukuba bahlele imiqulu emikhulu yokwaziswa ngokushelela, nakuba kuphakamisa ukukhathazeka mayelana nokungafihliwe nokucwasana. Uma kusetshenziswa ngokusobala, i-Al ingenza ukuthembisana kube lula ngaphandle kokuzidela.

Ukuvimbela Amarekhodi Angenakuminyaniswa

Ubuchwepheshe bebshchain bunikeza amathuba okuvota okungangeni hlangothi nesimiso sokuhlela uhlelo lwezwe, lapho zonke izinqumo nentengiselwano zibhalelwe kumphathi okwazi ukuhlolwa. Nakuba kusekhona ukuhlola, amapulatifomu anezitini angathuthukisa ukwethembana ezinqubweni zokuthembisana ngokuqinisekisa ukuthi imiphumela ayinakushintshwa ngemva kwalokho.

Izimo Ezivelele Zokubusa

Ngaphandle kokubonana, ukubusa okubambisana kuhilela izakhamuzi ekwenzeni izinqumo nokufeza izinhlelo zangempela. Ukuveza izinkonzo zomphakathi − njengezindawo zomphakathi ezilawulwa umphakathi noma isayensi yezakhamuzi — kubhula umngcele phakathi kukahulumeni nolawulwa. Lezi zimo zidinga amazinga aphezulu okuthembana kanye namandla kodwa zingaveza amakhambi amasha nasekelwe ngokwezimiso ezifanele.

Izindinganiso Zembulunga Yonke Zokuhlanganyela Ngokuzithandela Ezakhamuzini

Izinhlangano zomhlaba wonke ziqhubekela ekuthuthukiseni izindinganiso ezivamile zokuthembisana kwezakhamuzi, ezifana nezimiso ze-Open Government Data. i-Open Government Partership [ iyaqhubeka icwenga uhlelo lwayo, ikhuthaza amalungu ukuba amukele izisulu ezifuna ukuzuza izifiso. Njengoba lezizindinganiso zamukelwa kabanzi, zinikeza uphawu lokuhlola intuthuko nokuhlanganyela imikhuba emihle.

Isiphetho: Ukuhlanganyela NjengoMcimbi Wokubusa Okusayo, Okubonisayo

Isivumelwano sezakhamuzi asisona isenezelo sesimiso sokubusa sentando yeningi, kodwa sisenawo umshayeli oyinhloko wokukhanya nezindinganiso zokuziphatha ezisekela ukwethembana phakathi kwabantu nezinhlangano zabo. Ngokuvula izenzo zikahulumeni ukuze zihlolwe umphakathi, zidala iziteshi zokulandisa, futhi ziveza amazwi ahlukeneyo ekwenzeni inqubo, ukubopha kuguqula ukubusa kwenqubo evaliwe kube umzamo obambisana. Ubufakazi obuvela ekuhloleni kwezendaba njengoPorto Alegree, iOpen Governmentership, ne-apul bubonisa ukuthi lapho izakhamuzi zihileleke ngokunenzuzo, inkohlakalo incishiswa, imithombo yomphakathi isetshenziswa ngokufanelekile, futhi ukufaneleka kukahulumeni kuyaqiniswa.

Nokho ukufinyelela lemiphumela kudinga umzamo wenhloso wokunqoba imingcele yokunganaki, ukungalingani, nokumelana nezinhlangano. Ohulumeni kumelwe bafake imali emfundweni, kwezobuchwepheshe, nakuyikho ukuklanywa okungahlangene, kuyilapho izakhamuzi kumelwe zihlale ziqaphile futhi zithatha indima yazo ngokuzikhandla ekubuseni. Ikusasa liphethe amathuluzi athembisayo [1] kusukela e-Al ukuya ekuvimbeleni i-Anchain(*) kodwa ubuchwepheshe bodwa ngeke buthathe indawo yesibopho esiyisisekelo sokulawula. Ekugcineni, ithonya lokuthembisa kwezakhamuzi ukuba ngcono nokuziphatha kuxhomeke ekukhetheni okuhlangene: ukwakha izimiso ezizazisayo izwi lanoma yimuphi umuntu, futhi zibambe labo abanegunya kubantu abakhonzayo.