Table of Contents
Isingeniso: Isisekelo Sokulandisa Kwentando Yeningi
Ukulandisa kukahulumeni kuyikhothamo lentando yeningi. Iqinisekisa ukuthi izikhulu zomphakathi zinecala ngezenzo zazo nezinqumo. Esinye sezici ezibucayi kakhulu zalokhu kulandisa kuwukuthola ukwaziswa komphakathi. Ngaphandle kokubona ngapha nangapha, izakhamuzi azinakwenza izinqumo ezinolwazi noma zigcine abaholi bazo benesibopho sokulandisa. Enkathini yezimiso eziyinkimbinkimbi nemininingwane eminingi yamanani, ilungelo lokwazi ukuthi ukufinyelela amarekhodi kahulumeni, izimali, izinhlelo zomthetho, kanye nemininingwane yomphakathi kunika izakhamuzi amandla okuhlanganyela ngokunenzuzo ekulawuleni, ukuphatha ukuphatha kabi, ukuqaphela inguquko. Kuvela emikhandlwini yendawo kuya ephalazweni, isimiso esiphathelene nomthetho esisemthethweni esisemthethweni esilawulayo.
Nokho, nakuba inzuzo yokubona inconywa emhlabeni wonke, ukuthatha kwayo akulingani. Ohulumeni abaningi basasebenza ngemuva kweminyango evalekile, befihla ukonakala noma ukungenamandla ezindongeni zombuso. Lesi sihloko sihlola ukuthi kungani umphakathi uthola ulwazi, izithiyo eziphikelelayo, kanye namasu asetshenziswayo, okuhlanganisa amathuluzi anamuhla angenza uhulumeni avuleke ngempela.
Indima Yokubonisa Isilinganiso Ekubuseni
Ukubonisana kwemisebenzi kahulumeni kuthuthukisa ukwethembana phakathi kwezakhamuzi nabaholi bazo. Uma abantu bethola ukwaziswa ngemisebenzi kahulumeni, bangaqonda kangcono ukuthi izinqumo zenziwa kanjani nokuthi imithombo yomphakathi isetshenziswa kanjani. Lokhu kucacisa kunciphisa ukusola futhi kwakha ubuhlobo obakhayo phakathi kombuso nomphakathi.
Ukubona gcaluku futhi kusebenza njengesithiyo esinamandla ekusebenziseni kabi amandla. Uma izikhulu zazi ukuthi izenzo zazo zihlolwa umphakathi, zithambekele kakhulu ekwenzeni ngokwezimiso nangaphakathi komthetho. Ukucwaninga kulokhu kubonisa ukuthi amazwe anamazinga aphakeme okubonayo aphansi kakhulu enkohlakalo nanamandla ezomnotho. Ngokwesibonelo, i-Corruption Perceptions Index ngokuvamile aguqula imikhuba yolwazi ngokufumbathisa okuphansi nezinkonzo zomphakathi ezingcono.
Ukuhlanganyela Nokuhlanganyela Okukahulumeni Ngobuchwepheshe
Ukubonakala kwalendlela kukhuthaza ukubophana kwezakhamuzi. Izakhamuzi ezingathola imali kahulumeni, imizuzu yemihlangano, nezihlongozo zezimiso zihlonyiselwe kangcono ukunikeza impendulo, ukuthatha izimemezelo, nokuvota okusekelwe emaqinisweni kunokuba kusekelwe ekukhulumeni. Lengxoxo yendlela emibili iqinisa izinhlangano zentando yeningi futhi yenza inqubo ihlanganiseke kakhulu. Amazwe anjenge-Estonia, aqala ukusungula i-evernance, abonisa ukuthi amathuluzi okuveza imishini angandisa ukuvota nokuthatha iqhaza komphakathi ezimisweni zomthetho.
Ukunciphisa Ukonakala Ngokuvula Inkululeko
Inkohlakalo ichuma ekusithekeni. ngokwenza izivumelwano, amarekhodi ezimali, nezimemezelo zemali ezitholakalayo obala, kuvala izikhala ezivumela ukuxhumene. I-Open Government sharter [, isu lokuthatha izivumelwano eziningi ezihilela amazwe angaphezu kuka-70, iye yafaka ubufakazi obuningi lapho izinguquko zokuthola ukwaziswa ezivulekile zawanciphisa khona amazinga enkohlakalo. Ngokwesibonelo, ukusakaza ukwaziswa komphakathi e-Ukraine kwaholela ekulondolozweni okukhulu nasekuncipheni kwemisweni kwezindawo phakathi kwezikhulu nezakhiwo.
Ukuthuthukisa Izinkonzo Zomphakathi
Lapho izakhamuzi zibona ukuthi imali isetshenziswa kanjani, zingafuna imali engcono yamaRandi akhokhelwa intela. Ukubona gca kuvumela ukuqhathaniswa komsebenzi ezikhungweni, ezindaweni nasezikhathini zesikhathi, kubangele ukucindezela kokuncintisana ukuze kuthuthukiswe. Izikole, izibhedlela, nemisebenzi yezemisebenzi yezemisebenzi yemvelo iphumelela kakhulu uma imiphumela yazo ibonakala emphakathini.
Izinzuzo Zokuthola Ukwaziswa Komphakathi
Ukuthola ukwaziswa komphakathi kunezinzuzo eziningi ezibangela uhulumeni olandisayo.
Ukwazi Ukwakha Izakhamuzi
Uma izakhamuzi zikwazi ukuthola ukwaziswa kukahulumeni, zingazenza izinqumo ezinolwazi ngemithetho kanye nokhetho. Imvume yokuvota ephalamende, ukuhlelwa kwemisebenzi yezomthetho, kanye nokuhlelwa kwemali kuvumela abavoti ukuba bahlole iziqu nabazohlolela ukusebenza kwabo kwangempela. Data.gov[[FLT] isinyathelo sokuqala eUnited States, ngokwesibonelo, senza izinkulungwane zemininingwane ekhona, yenza ukuba izintatheli, abacwaningi, nabashisekeli bezokuhlola izimo zempilo, imfundo, nendawo ezungezile. Lokhu kwezakhamuzi ezifundile yinjini yentando yentando yeningi esabelayo.
Ukuqondisa Okukhuliswe Kakhudlwana
Ukubona ngcono kuvumela ukuqondisa izenzo zikahulumeni zezinhlangano zomphakathi nezigadayo. Imishini yokuhlola izibalo, izindikimba ezimelene nokonakala, kanye namaqembu omphakathi incike emarekhodini avulekile ukuze aqaphele ukuthobela imithetho nokubona ukungavumelani. Uma ukwaziswa kutholakala ngokukhululekile, ukuqondisa kuba umthwalo wemfanelo owodwa kunemisebenzi elinganiselwe. Ngokwesibonelo, i-UK’s Freedom of Information Act iye yasetshenziswa yizintatheli ukudalula ukusetshenziswa kabi kwezimali nezimiso zomphakathi.
Isikhuthazo Sokufutha
Ukutholakala komphakathi ekwazisweni kunganika abantu amandla okubika ukuziphatha okubi ngaphandle kokwesaba ukuziphindisela. Uma umcuphi wekhwela azi ukuthi amaphepha angaphansi asekhona kakade noma angacelwa ngemithetho evulekile yamarekhodi, anendlela ephephile yokudalula okubi. Ngaphezu kwalokho, isivikelo esingokomthetho sabavuli bempempe, kanye nokubona, kwenza kube nzima ukufihla ukuziphatha okubi. Indaba ye FOIA eUnited States] iholele ekukhipheni amarekhodi aveza yonke into ebangelwa ukuphamba okunga okungalawuleki kwempi ukuze isetshenziswe ekuchitheni udoti.
Izinzuzo Zezomnotho Nezenhlalo
Ngaphandle kokulandisa, imininingwane kahulumeni evulekile ibangela ukusungulwa kwezomnotho. Izinkampani zangasese, ukuqala, nokungakhiqizi inzuzo zisebenzisa ukwaziswa komphakathi ukuze zakhe ama-apps, zihlaziye izimo zezentengiselwano, futhi zithuthukise ukuhanjiswa kwenkonzo. Ngokwesibonelo, ukwaziswa okuthatha isikhathi sangempela kusiza abacwaningi ukuba bakwazi ukuthatha i-apps, futhi ukwaziswa kwezempilo kusiza abacwaningi ukuba balandele ukuqubuka kwezifo. Lezi zinzuzo zomnotho zithethelela ukutshala imali ezisekelwe ezisekelweni ezisekelwe ezisekelweni ezingeni elingaphandle.
Imisebenzi Yesakhelo Engokomthetho Yokufinyelela Ulwazi
Ilungelo lokuthola ulwazi lukahulumeni lihlanganiswe emithethweni emhlabeni wonke. Amazwe angaphezu kwekhulu aye amukela inkululeko yolwazi (FOI) athatha izenzo, nakuba ukuphumelela kwawo kuhluka kakhulu. Imithetho ye-FOI enamandla ihlanganisa izinqubo ezicacile zezicelo, izinketho eziqinile zezikhathi zokuphendula, izintelezi ezimngcipheko, kanye nezindikimba ezizimele. Izimiso 19 [ zinikeza imithetho enjalo yomhlaba wonke.
Izindlela Zokuthola Izindlela Eziqhathaniswayo
Amazwe anjengeSweden aye anemithetho yomphakathi kusukela ngo-1766, kuyilapho amanye, njenge-Indiya (2005 ne-South Africa (2000), ashaya umthetho wamuva kakhulu. I-Indian Right to Information Act (RTI) iphawuleka kakhulu ngoba ihlanganisa izindleko eziphansi nezijeziso eziqinile zokungatholi mvume, okuphumela ezinhlamvwini zezicelo ngonyaka. Lokhu kuye kwanika izakhamuzi zasemaphandleni amandla okugcina izikhulu zendawo zinecala, kunciphise ukonakala ezinhlelweni zezenhlalakahle, futhi kuthuthukise ukuthunyelwa kwenkonzo.
Ubuthakathaka Obuvamile Emithethweni YeFAI
Naphezu kwentuthuko, imithetho eminingi ye-FOI inezaba. Ukungatholi mvume yamazwe esizwe, ukuhlelwa kwezindawo zokuphepha eziyimfihlo ngokweqile, nezindleko eziphakeme kungavimbela ukusetshenziswa. Ezinye izifundazwe zivumela izindleko ezingenamkhawulo zokufuna nokukopisha, zikhiphela phambili izakhamuzi ezimpofu enqubweni. Ezinye zibeka “imfihlo yezentengiselwano” yezinombolo ezingacacile ezifihla izivumelwano. Imizamo yokuguqula igxile ekunciphiseni imingcele nokumisa abaphathi bezokwaziswa abazimele ekunqandeni izingxabano.
Izinselele Zokuthola Ithuba Lomphakathi
Naphezu kwezinzuzo ezicacile, kunezinselele ezinkulu zokuqinisekisa ukuthi umphakathi uyakwazi ukuthola ukwaziswa.
Ukumelana Nemibuso Yasebuthweni Lase - Australia
Ezinye izikhulu zikahulumeni zingamelana nokukhanya ngenxa yokwesaba ukuhlolwa, ukulahlekelwa amandla, noma ukulawulwa. Abaphathi bama-ofisi abajwayele ukusebenza ngemuva kweminyango evaliwe ngokuvamile babheka izicelo zomlando ezivulekile njengeziphazamisayo. Bangase bephuze ukusabela, bathi amarekhodi awekho, noma indawo yamarekhodi kumafomethi angafinyeleli. Ushintsho lwempucuko ludingeka kohulumeni ukuze babheke ukubonakala ngaphandle njengenqondo, hhayi usongo.
Ukuntuleka Kwemithombo Yengcebo
Izinhlangano eziningi azinazo izinto ezidingekayo zokunikeza ukwaziswa ngokuphumelelayo. Amarekhodi ephepha ashintshiwe, izisebenzi eziqeqesha izinqubo ze-FOI, kanye nokunakekela izinhlelo ze-website zidinga isikhathi nemali. Ohulumeni abancane bendawo, ikakhulukazi emazweni asathuthuka, bavame ukulwa nokuhlangabezana nesidingo esifunwayo. Ukutholakala komphakathi ngaphandle kwezimali ezanele kuholela ekuphenduleni kancane, ekunciphiseni izicelo eziqondile ezihloselwe ukuvikela.
Izithiyo Ezingokomthetho
Imithetho nezimiso ngezinye izikhathi zingavimbela ukutholakala kokwaziswa. Ukungavunyelwe kwe-Vague ngenxa ye- “sciommental,”“ inzuzo yomuntu siqu,” noma “izithakazelo zomuntu siqu” zingasetshenziswa kabi ukuze zingangeni zincwadi okufanele zibonwe umphakathi. Kwamanye amazwe, imithetho iphazamisa ukunyatheliswa kwezimfihlo zikahulumeni ngaphandle kwesimiso sokudalula esingokomthetho, okuthusa uphengululo. Izinguquko kumelwe zilinganisele imibandela engokomthetho eyimfihlo nezokuphepha ngokumelene nelungelo lomphakathi lokwazi.
Izimpikiswano Zobuchwepheshe Nezokwaziswa
Ngisho noma ukwaziswa kutholakala, kungase kube kumafomethi okunzima ukusebenzisa(-PDFs), amafomethi afakelweyo, noma ama-data anezikhombi ezifingqiwe. Ukuntuleka kokwaziswa okufundeka ngomshini kuvimbela ukuhlaziywa nokusetshenziswa. Ngaphezu kwalokho, izinkinga zezinga lokwaziswa njengezindinganiso ezilahlekile, izincazelo eziguquguqukayo, kanye nokwaziswa okuphelelwe isikhathi kunciphisa ukwethenjelwa. Ukuthatha ama-data kumelwe kuthinta lezizici zobuchwepheshe ukuze kube usizo ngempela.
Izinqubo Zokuthuthukisa Ukutholakala Kolwazi
Ukuze kunqotshwe lezi zinselele, kungasetshenziswa amasu amaningana ukuze kuthuthukiswe ukutholakala kokwaziswa komphakathi.
Izinguquko Ezingokomthetho
Ukufakwa kwenkululeko eqinile yemithetho yolwazi kungasiza ekuthuthukiseni ukubonakala. Izinguquko eziyinhloko zihlanganisa ukunciphisa izikhathi zokusabela, ukwehlisa noma ukuqeda izindleko, ukwenza ukufakwa kwemvume yokuthulula izigwegwe (lapho wonke amarekhodi enziwa obala ngaphandle kokuba akhululwe ngokuqondile), nokumisa izimiso ezibophekile zemininingwane ethile (izivumelwano, izivumelwano, ama-aflications). Izindikimba ezizimele eziqondisayo ezinamandla okuqinisekisa ukugcinwa kwamandla, njengabaphathi-lwazi, zingaqinisekisa ukuvumelana.
Ukuzinza Kobuchwepheshe
Ukugcwalisa amapulatifomu okusebenza nge-inthanethi ukuze kuhlangane nomniningo kungenza ukwaziswa kutholakale kakhulu. Ohulumeni kufanele bamukele izimiso zedata ezivulekile: shicilela imininingwane efundeka ngomshini, engekho-proprietaryformat (CSV, XML, JSON); sebenzisa izinhlelo zokuhlela (APIS) ukuze ungene ngokoqobo esikhathini; futhi ugcine amatheku aphakathi njenge data.gov.uk[. Ubuchwepheshe bubuye busebenzise iproctive relation(proficiation-jolish-*[publish] amarekhodi ngaphambi kokuba iceliwe.
Imikhankaso Yokuxwayisa Umphakathi
Ukufundisa izakhamuzi ngamalungelo azo okuthola ulwazi kungabanika amandla okufuna ukuba sobala. Abantu abaningi abayazi imithetho ye-FOI noma bayithola inqubo isabisa. Izicelo ezilula, iziqondisi ezinemifanekiso, nezindawo zokuqeqeshela umphakathi zinganciphisa izithiyo. ENdiya, abashisekeli bokudlulisela ukwaziswa ngakwesokudla bavame ukuthi “izenzakalo ezithinta umphakathi lapho izakhamuzi zifunda khona ukuhlanganisa izicelo ze-RTI bese zihlanganyela imiphumela emphakathini.
Ukwakha Isiko Lokukhululeka Embusweni
Kubalulekile ukuqeqesha izisebenzi zomphakathi ngokubaluleka kokukhanya, kunokuba zikubheke njengomthwalo. Imisebenzi ingahlanganisa ukusabela okufike ngesikhathi kwezicelo ze-FOI. Isibopho sobuholi esivela phezulu(padent, indunankulu, ungqongqoshe) uphawu lokuthi ukuvuleka kwecala kuyinto ebaluleke kakhulu. Izibonelo ezifana ne-UK “Transparate Agenda" ibonisa indlela engokombangazwe engaguqula ngayo impucuko ye-bureaucratic.
Ukuhlola Izenzakalo Zezinyathelo Zokubona Ingaphandle Eziphumelelayo
Ukuhlola izindlela eziphumelelayo zokubonana kunganikeza ukuqonda okuwusizo ngemikhuba emihle.
Ukuvuleka Kobuhlobo Bukahulumeni (OGP)
Inyathelo lembulunga yonke elikhuthaza ukuba sobala nomthwalo wemfanelo kuhulumeni. Amazwe angamalungu abophekile ekuthuthukiseni izinqubo zesizwe ezinezinguquko eziqinile, njengokutholana, ukuhlela ukuhlelwa kwemali okukhululekile, nokusekela imali yomphakathi. Inqubo yokuzihlolela ye-OGP ezimele isiza ekuthuthukeni kwendlela futhi ihlanganyele izifundo emazweni angama-70+. Ngokwesibonelo, iGeorgia yasebenzisa izibopho zokulungisa isimiso sayo sokuthola imali, isindisa izigidi ngemncintiswano eyandayo.
Imininingwane.gov kanye nemininingwane evulekile efanayo
Iwebhusayithi kahulumeni wase-U.S. .gov inikeza ukufinyelela ingcebo yokwaziswa komphakathi, kusukela ekuhlelekeni kwesimo sezulu kuya kwizibalo zempilo. Iye yashukumisa iziteshi ezifanayo emhlabeni wonke, njengaseCanada open.canada.[ kanye ne-data ye-EU. La mapulatifomu avumela abathuthukisi, abacwaningi, nezintatheli ukuba bakhe izicelo futhi baveze ukuqonda okungenakuba nokwenzeka. Umphumela ophawulekayo uwukusetshenziswa kokwaziswa okuvulekile ekuhleleni izimali, ukunciphisa ukukhwaanisa.
Inkululeko Yokwaziswa Iyasebenza
Izenzakalo eziphumelelayo lapho izakhamuzi ziye zasebenzisa khona izicelo zokuthola ukwaziswa okugxekayo. Ku-UK, izintatheli zasebenzisa i-FOI ukuveza izindleko zeqiniso zeMpi ye-Iraq kanye nobungako becala “lokuhlasela kwe-pane”. ENdiya, abashisekeli be-RTI baveza ukonakala ekusakazeni ukudla okungasho lutho futhi baphoqelela uhulumeni ukuba ahlele isimiso. Lezi zibonelo zibonisa ukuthi uma ilungelo lokwaziswa lisekelwa abasebenzisi abazimisele, lingaveza ukulandisa okuqinile.
Isibonelo Sikahulumeni Wase - Estonia Esitonia Esisebenzisa Izinombolo
I-Estonia ima njengomholi wembulunga yonke we-e-e-gevernance kanye nokukhanya. Cishe zonke izinkonzo zikahulumeni zise-inthanethi, futhi izakhamuzi zingathola amarekhodi azo ezokwelapha, intela yamafayela, kanye nokuvota nge-ID elondekile. Okubalulekile, i-X-Road plat ivumela ukuhwebelana kokwaziswa okulondekile phakathi kwezinhlangano kuyilapho iqinisekisa ukuthi izakhamuzi zibona ukuthi ubani ongenisela ukwaziswa kwazo [1] “umkhondo owe-oqudayo” ukuze zifune ukufihla imfihlo. Lesi simiso sinciphise kakhulu ukulibala kwe-bureaucracratic futhi sithuthukisa ukwethembana kwazo.
Indima Yobuchwepheshe Ekuboneni Okugqamile
Ubuchwepheshe banamuhla bunikeza amathuba angenakuqhathaniswa okwenza ukwaziswa kukahulumeni kutholakale, kuhlolwe futhi kuqondakala, kodwa ubuchwepheshe bodwa abuyona ikhambi; kumelwe buhlanganiswe nentando yezombangazwe nezimiso ezingokomthetho.
Izindinganiso Zokwaziswa Ezivulekile Ne - AP
Amafomethi avamile avumela ukwaziswa okuvela emithonjeni ehlukene ukuba kuhlanganiswe futhi kuhlaziywe. Izinhlelo zezinhlelo zezinhlelo zisiza ukuba ukwazi ukuthola ukwaziswa kwangempela okunjengesimo sezulu, izimoto, noma ukuhlelwa kwemali. Ngokwesibonelo, i-International Aid Transparection (IATATI) ihlela indlela imininingwane yosizo lokuthuthukisa ekhishwa ngayo, yenza abanikeli nabamukelayo bakwazi ukuthola izimali ngokuphumelelayo.
Ukuhlakanipha Okuklanywe Ngekhono Nemininingwane Emikhulu
I-AI ingasiza ekuhleleni futhi ihlaziye imiqulu emikhulu yamarekhodi kahulumeni, ibone ama-anomalie, futhi ifingxe izincwadi eziyinkimbinkimbi. Amathuluzi a-automat redaction angavikela imfihlo yomuntu siqu kuyilapho ekhipha lonke idokhumende. Nokho, amanani kumelwe abe nokuveza okusobala ukuze kugwenywe ubandlululo oluqinisiwe.
Ukuhlanganyela Esakhamuzini
Amathuluzi emishini anjengeziteshi zokuhlela imali, iziphakamiso zokusikisela, kanye nezinhloli ezinamabhodi ezixhumene zisiza izakhamuzi ukuba zithonye ngokuqondile izinqumo zikahulumeni. Izibonelo zihlanganisa i-Decidim eSpain nase-vTaiwan eTaiwan, eye yathuthukisa izinhlelo nokwaneliseka komphakathi.
Iziqondiso Zesikhathi Esizayo Zohulumeni Ovulekile
Isicelo sokubona ngaphandle sixazululeka. Imizamo yesikhathi esizayo izogxila ekwambuleni okunenzuzo(-) umphakathi ngaphandle kokulinda isicelo. Ohulumeni bazama kakhulu “ukuvula ngezimiso ezinephutha”, lapho ama-data akhishwa njalo ngaphandle kokuba kunesizathu esiphoqelelayo sokubavimba.
Okunye ukuthambekela ukuhlanganiswa kokubonakala ngaphandle emklamweni wezinkonzo zomphakathi, oyaziwa ngokuthi “ukwaziswa okuvulekile ngokuklanywa.” Lokhu kusho ukwakha amakhono okwaziswa axhumanisa nezimiso ezintsha, kunokuba kusetshenziswe kamuva. Ngaphezu kwalokho, ukukhula kobuchwepheshe beblockchain kunikeza amathuba okungavimba ukungezwani kwentengiselwano kahulumeni, nakuba ukukwazi ukumelana nokusetshenziswa kwamandla kusenezinselele.
I-United Nations’s Sustainable Development Meendo 16,10 ifuna ngokukhethekile ukuba umphakathi uthole ukwaziswa nesivikelo senkululeko eyisisekelo. Njengoba amazwe amaningi amukela izibopho zikahulumeni ezisobala, ukucindezela kontanga nokufunda okukodwa kuyoqhubekisela phambili.
Isiphetho: Indlela Engaphambili
Ukulandisa kukahulumeni kubalulekile ekusebenziseni idemokrasi esebenzayo, futhi ukufinyelela ukwaziswa komphakathi kubalulekile ukuze kufinyelele lokhu kulandisa. Ngokukhuthaza ukuba sobala, ukunqoba izinselele, nokufunda ezithathelwe phambili eziphumelelayo, singadala i-operation egcwele futhi sithembise isakhamuzi. Uhambo olusuka kuhulumeni ovaliwe ludinga ukukhokha ngokuqhubekayo, ukutshala izimpahla, ukushintshela amasiko ezinhlanganweni. Nokho imivuzo iphakeme: ukonakala, izinkonzo zomphakathi eziphumelela kakhulu, kanye nomphakathi lapho izakhamuzi zisebenza nohulumeni endaweni yokubusa.
Isakhamuzi ngasinye sinendima esinayo. I-fail enkulu yesicelo sokwaziswa, isekela imisebenzi yokwaziswa evulekile, noma joyina iqembu lendawo lokuveza iziqu zokwaziswa. Uma ulwazi lugeleza ngokukhululekile, amandla ahlolwa, futhi idemokrasi ichuma. Ekugcineni, uhulumeni ovulekile nolandisayo ukhonza abantu bakhe ngokuphumelelayo.